top of page
Search

The Rise and Fall of Brian Kelly

In a move that's sending shockwaves through the college football world, LSU has fired head coach Brian Kelly midway through his fourth season with the Tigers. The decision, announced by LSU Athletics Director Scott Woodward, comes on the heels of a brutal 49-24 loss to Texas A&M that dropped the Tigers to 5-3 on the season. It's the end of a $100 million, 10-year dream turned nightmare, with reports suggesting the buyout could cost LSU upwards of $54 million. Frank Wilson has been named interim head coach as the program scrambles to regroup.


For Tigers fans, this is a gut punch – a program that handed Kelly the keys to Death Valley in late 2021, hoping he'd replicate his success at Notre Dame. But for those who bleed blue and gold under his watch at Notre Dame, it's vindication served cold. Kelly's tenure with the Irish was a rollercoaster of highs, heartbreaks, and head-scratching decisions that left scars still fresh four years after he bolted for Baton Rouge.


Kelly’s Underachieving Chapter at Notre Dame


Brian Kelly arrived at Notre Dame in 2010 like a man on a mission, fresh off a national championship at Grand Valley State and stints that turned Cincinnati into a Big East powerhouse. He inherited a program reeling from Charlie Weiss's flameout, with fans desperate for stability. And for a while, Kelly delivered. His early years were a masterclass in resurgence. In 2012, he led the Irish to a 12-0 regular season, capped by a BCS National Championship appearance against Alabama. That squad, powered by Manti Te'o's Heisman-caliber defense and a gritty Everett Golson at QB, restored hope in South Bend. By 2018, he'd notched four double-digit win seasons, including a College Football Playoff berth, and his overall record stood at an impressive 104-35.


But the shine wore off faster than a South Bend winter. Critics – and there were plenty – pointed to the disappointing 2016 season as the beginning of the end for Kelly at Notre Dame. Something changed in Brian Kelly that season as it began to appear that he was no longer loyal to the university, but preferred to spend time on the golf course. Recruiting rollercoasters plagued him, too: elite classes followed by inexplicable misses, leaving the Irish perpetually talented but rarely transcendent. And then there were the optics – the sideline tirades, the perceived lack of loyalty. The breaking point came in the 2021 season. Notre Dame was 11-1, cruising toward another playoff shot, when COVID protocols derailed their postseason dreams. Whispers of discontent grew louder. Then, on the eve of the Fiesta Bowl, Kelly shocked the world by jumping ship to LSU, signing a massive deal amid reports of contract disputes and a desire for a personal chef. The Irish Nation was left reeling, but not without hope.


Where Were You When You Heard the News?


I remember the moment it all crystallized for me like it was yesterday. I had long called for a coaching change as Kelly’s recruiting was falling, his teams were boring to watch, and he didn’t come across as the most genuine man. I watched a great basketball game between Notre Dame and Illinois. As the game went on, you began, you began to hear chants of “Kelly left” and “You’re Coach is gone!” It started in the bleachers, then spread like wildfire. I quickly looked at my phone and read the headline that Kelly was leaving Notre Dame for LSU. I was shocked, but felt like a giant weight had been lifted as a fan. It felt like a chapter was finally closing on a man who'd never truly bought into Notre Dame.


A New Hope


Looking back now, from the vantage of this LSU implosion, I'm profoundly thankful Kelly walked away when he did. Notre Dame didn't fire him – they elevated him out the door, handing the reins to Marcus Freeman, a 36-year-old defensive whiz who'd been Kelly's own hire in 2021.


Freeman isn't just an upgrade; he's the anti-Kelly in the best ways. Where Kelly micromanaged and moped, Freeman empowers – his “Gold Standard" philosophy feels genuine, not scripted. More importantly, he's all in: a Notre Dame family man, a recruiter who sells the Notre Dame way without caveats, and appears to care about every young man on the roster genuinely. The Irish are tougher, more resilient, playing with the fire that Kelly's squads often lacked. Freeman's the coach – and the man – Notre Dame deserves for the long haul, steering us toward another championship without the drama.


Goodbye Brian

LSU fans, you've got my sympathies – and my best wishes. Kelly brought flashes of brilliance to Tiger Stadium, including the 2022 10-win debut and the Heisman buzz surrounding Jayden Daniels. But the SEC's meat grinder exposed his flaws – inconsistent defenses, quarterback roulette, and a sideline style that alienated more than it inspired. As you hunt for his successor, know this: sometimes, a clean break is the spark you need.


For Notre Dame faithful, Kelly's firing is poetic justice. We survived the storm; now the boys are back, and we’re looking for another college football playoff appearance. 


Go Irish!

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page